We - my husband and I and a friend - stayed in
this 2-bdrm place and quite liked it because:
1. It is in the old town, in the pintxos epicenter in the world, which is where we wanted to be.
2. Besides being in the great Parte Vieja, it is an easy walk to the waterfront
3. The wonderful restaurant Bodegon Alejandro is in the basement, and the great Mercado de la Bretxa, frequented by all the starred chefs of San Sebastian, is half a block away.
But I can see it may not be for everyone:
1. It is on the 5th floor with no lift. (But somehow with the way the staircase is done, it is an easy climb. Honestly we never minded it.)
2. The smell from the kitchen of Bodegon Alexandro sometimes comes into the apartment. Again we didn't mind. Kust made us want to eat there again.
3. One of the 2 bedrooms is not completely closed off from the dining/living room area. The wall only comes up to counter-height, and the rest is shielded by blinds that can be lifted up. We like an airy room and chose to stay in that room in fact.
It may not be for everyone.